Hamilton’s Shoutout: On a Trope that Silences

Main Article Content

Miranda Brookshier

Abstract

Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Grammy-winning musical, Hamilton, is praised for its integration of a diverse cast in the production of “a story about American then, told by America now.” This show is applauded for its use of contemporary rap and hip-hop music and its portrayal of Founding Fathers by men of color, thus allowing all viewers to revel in a shared, triumphant past. Despite Hamilton’s renown, critics have challenged the hypocrisy in Miranda’s casting, which allows people of color to portray the very white men who perpetuated a cycle of oppression through chattel slavery. While critics question the racialization of characters and the music, these historical analyses have failed to consider the lyrics’ influence in recapitulating a vision of the Revolutionary era as “whites only,” regardless of who is cast. In this essay, I argue that Hamilton’s success hinders on an incomplete view of the Founding Fathers, opting to memorialize their noble legacies and elide a troubling history with slavery. Through a close analysis of the show’s lyrics and a consideration into the intersections of race and gender, readers will see how this production ultimately centers white men and minimizes the experiences of enslavement for black women.

Article Details

Section
Articles